Smithereens

Tucked beneath Smithereens in the East Village, their intimate wine cellar transforms group dining into something magical, where exposed brick and flickering candlelight create the kind of underground sanctuary that makes every celebration feel conspiratorial and special. The $150 prix fixe showcases their New England heritage with impeccable lobster rolls and coastal classics that taste like summer on Cape Cod, while the surrounding wine bottles remind you that the best dinners happen when you lose track of time. Your group will leave feeling like they discovered a secret that's too good to share—though you absolutely will.