Palma

Palma's 200-year-old carriage house transforms group celebrations into something magical, with exposed brick walls and flickering candlelight creating an intimacy that feels worlds away from bustling Cornelia Street. The sprawling Italian menu shines in this setting—imagine passing platters of house-made pasta and wood-fired branzino while your party of up to 40 spills into the enchanting garden courtyard. This hidden West Village gem delivers the kind of authentic neighborhood trattoria experience that makes everyone feel like they've discovered New York's best-kept secret.